Food and music - the analogies between Indian music and food

When I arrived in Birmingham, I was told that the Indian food here is very famous. Don't ask me why isn't British cuisine - I don't know. I cook a lot, it is enjoyable (and to my finance). Thinking of cooking and composition, they have a lot in common. The article "Why Hindustani Musicians are Good Cooks: Analogies between Music and Food in North India" by Adrian McNeil is a good explanation of that. The title is very self-explaining.

According to McNeil, when you cook you have to identify the Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary ingredients. For chicken tikka masala, a very famous Indian dish invented in the UK. I reference the BBC recipe, hope it is better than fried rice.
  • Primary ingredients - Chicken, red peppers, onions, mango chutney, tomatoes
  • Secondary ingredients - tikka masala paste, double cream, yogurt
  • Tertiary ingredients - ginger, garlic, oil, butter
In Indian music that McNeil suggests
  • Primary - basic scale, mode.
  • Secondary - vadi (the note of a rag requiring greatest emphasis); samvydl (the note requiring second greatest emphasis); chalan(outlines hierarchy of notes); pakad (characteristic phrase[s]). 
  • Tertiary - gamaks (ornamentation); shrutis (microtone)
If apply it to Western music
  • Primary - Melody, rhythm
  • Secondary - Harmony, voicing 
  • Tertiary - Articulation, phasing
This contributes to the concept of the hierarchy of primary, secondary, and tertiary elements. If the chicken is missing, the dish has to change the name; if any secondary, tertiary is missing, still eatable but the result is far from satisfaction. However, if any secondary or tertiary element is too much, like too much salt, the dish is spoiled. As a composer or a performer, it is interesting to view these music parameters from the food perspective and maintain the balance of different ingredients.

Reference:

McNeil, A. (1993) Why Hindustani Musicians are Good Cooks: Analogies between Music and Food in North India. Asian music. [Online] 25 (1/2), 69–80.

Location: 英國伯明罕伯明翰

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Post-spectralism influence on tuning

According to Helmholtz (2011), a musical note is due to the fundamental frequency and the quality of a musical sound is due to the presence of upper partials. For traditional western music, pitch perception is mainly fundamental, rather than the frequencies in the spectrum which Teodorescu-Ciocanea (2003) describes as a “note proper” tradition. The spectralism composers shifted the domain from absolute pitches, intervals and chords to the spectrum. Spectral music is a complex approach to timbre, Teodorescu-Ciocanea (2003) classified 9 tendencies and their possibilities in spectral music. To conclude the techniques, tuning the frequencies according to the harmonic series is the major approach; while working with noise, generated digitally and/or extended techniques on instruments, is a sort of timbral dissonance which dilutes the pitch perception of a musical sound. Teodorescu-Ciocanea describes inharmonicity as the combination of frequencies that are not integral multiples of the funda
Read more

Haba's field shifting - and the expansion of traditional functional harmony

Image
Hába characterizes the quarter-tone gamut as separated into two fields, one half comprising the twelve conventional pitches, and the other half, shifting all the twelve notes by a quarter-tone, the twelve quarter-tone pitches. In harmony, Passages occur in which chords composed purely of conventional pitches alternate with chords composed purely of quarter-tone pitches. Two fields are not always rejecting each other when he equally divided a perfect 4th (5 semitones)into 2 equal intervals, equal 2.5 for each, the 0.5 quartertones always step into the other field. Sometimes, this fourth interval can be further divided into 2.5+2+0.5 or other permutations. This kind of splitting a fourth can be traced to ancient greek tetrachord, a scale of four notes, bounded by the interval of a perfect fourth. A chord across both fields, the chord spell like a flatter dominant 7th chord. the 7th harmonic on harmonic series is quite flat (-31cents). This chord combines both fields sounds better accordi
Read more

Temperament, Tuning, and Timbre -- the underrated trinity in music

 The trinity here is not about the Christianity faith, but similar to the idea of the Christian doctrine of it defines God as being one God existing in three coequal, the core and fundamental definition, temperament, tuning, and timbre (TTT) are the basic building blocks of music, yet, underrated and even neglected in our music education system. TTT correlates with each other. A note is played, it carries out a series of frequencies, the harmonic series. The series multiples from the fundamental frequency with a series of integers (1f 2f 3f 4f 5f 6f 7f 8f 9f 10f 11f 12f 13f...). The loudness of individual particles, and different patterns, creates different timbres. View the series in a different way, the combination of the integers creates intervals. The combination of the beginning of the series sounds more harmonious and vice versa; simple ratios sound pure and vice versa. The pure perfect 5th interval is based on the ratio of 2:3 (2nd and 3rd harmonics at the same time), Pytheogoro
Read more